ACCEPTABLE I-9 DOCUMENTS & best practices
Nail I-9 Document Compliance Every Time
Whether you’re hiring in-person or remotely, this free resource helps you stay compliant, consistent, and avoid costly mistakes when verifying Section 2 documents.
130+ SHRM reviews
Don’t Risk Even One Small I-9 Error
Form I-9 Document Mistakes Are Easy to Make
All it takes is one overlooked detail on Form I-9 to put your company at risk for steep penalties. Without a clear I-9 document process in place, your team may be:
- Illegally requesting documents
- Accepting invalid or expired IDs
- Missing deadlines for Section 1 and 2
- Questioning when to escalate non-compliance issues
- Mismanaging remote verification
Master the I-9 Verification Process
Spot I-9 Issues Before They Become Risks
Managing I-9 document compliance doesn't have to be overwhelming. This I-9 Document Verification Checklist simplifies the process with:
- Clear breakdown of the Lists of Acceptable Documents
- Red flags to look for when reviewing identification
- Tips to avoid discrimination and over-documentation
- Guidance on employee identity and work authorization document inspection
- When to escalate employee document issues to HR or Legal
Take the Next Step to Protect Your Organization
Discover how OutSolve’s I-9 employment verification solution can protect you from costly violations, streamline verification, and keep your Form I-9s audit-ready. Contact us now to safeguard your business.
Why Download the I-9 Document Checklist
Don’t risk thousands of dollars in penalties for mistakes that could have been avoided. This checklist will help you master what is needed for I-9 document compliance.
Avoid Costly Mistakes
Get guidance on what documents are acceptable, what to avoid, and how to stay compliant.
Train Your Team
Use this checklist to reduce errors, prevent over-documentation, and standardize onboarding procedures.
Protect Your Organization
Spot red flags, meet deadlines, and know when to escalate issues to HR or Legal before they become compliance liabilities.
Partner with OutSolve
Our I-9 consultants are here to offer guidance and best practices on I-9 document compliance.

Know How to Handle Section 2 Documents
Download our I-9 Documents checklist today to help your team navigate I-9 compliance with confidence and consistency.
01
Learn which documents are acceptable for Section 2 (and which aren’t).
02
Identify red flags that could lead to costly mistakes.
03
Know what to do when documents look questionable.
We have partnered with Outsolve for many years. The expertise and guidance they provide us as an organization is important to our company and our values. We look forward to a continued partnership in the years to come.
Chelesy Hanes
EVP HR, Fike Corporation
The OutSolve staff have been professional, knowledgeable and very attentive to our needs as a company. They have been a valuable resource and really take the time to explain all parts of the process from data gathering to the final output.
Sierra Gilder
Human Resources | AUSTAL USA
Outsolve has proven to be a very valuable resource for our OFCCP compliance needs. Becky Crowder in particular has been great to work with, as she is extremely knowledgeable, thorough and responsive. I highly recommend Outsolve’s services.
Tracy Grashoff
Vera Bradley, Inc.
Outsolve is a wonderful partner and resource! Their expertise and attention to detail has been invaluable to our organization in navigating the OFCCP landscape to ensure compliance. Truly cannot say enough positive things about Outsolve!
Gayle Higgs
OutPerform Management, Inc.
Outsolve has been an outstanding partner of ours for many years. As our business and state/federal compliance requirements have evolved, Outsolve (and specifically, Christina Liang) has been proactive and thorough to minimize the work burden for our team - allowing us to focus on running our business.
Jeff Streb
Director Human Resources, Ingram Micro
We have partnered with Outsolve for many years. The expertise and guidance they provide us as an organization is important to our company and our values. We look forward to a continued partnership in the years to come.
Chelesy Hanes
EVP HR, Fike Corporation
Checklist FAQs
Find answers and general information quickly. Still have questions? Shoot us a message!
-
What documents are acceptable for Form I-9?
Employees must provide one document from List A or one from List B and one from List C.
-
Can I ask employees for specific documents, like a driver’s license and Social Security card?
No! Never ask an employee to provide a specific document, instead provide them with the list of acceptable documents and let them choose.
-
What should I do if a document looks fake or doesn't match the employee?
The checklist shows you what red flags to look for, how to respond respectfully, and when to escalate to HR or Legal.
-
How do we verify remote employees’ documents?
In order to remotely verify Section 2 documents, employers must be enrolled in E-Verify. Consult the checklist for other tips on remote verification.

Protect your organization from costly mistakes and reputational damage
Download the I-9 Document Checklist and strengthen your compliance today.